The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[vejitadmc]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

unfair to the person getting the one dog! not fair at all.

Other opinions?

I think it is a pretty fair trade, but you might be able to get more for a black advent because they are so rediculously popular. But the angel dog is already almost fair I believe.
Get another opinion just in case though :3

[tawnypelt3]

Fair?
I have no idea with these items. Thanks!

unfair to the person getting the one dog! not fair at all.

Other opinions?

I'm usually extremely cautious with big trades (I mean, BA), but I'd like to try and help you, since everyone else is pretty unsure, too. Looking at the Rares List, the grey dragon is only one line below the BA, and the Angel Advent is one below the dragon, so if you want to get technical, I would say it's overpay ONLY IN THE SENSE OF ACTUAL WORTH. NOT in the sense of demand. Plus that goblin dog (is that what it's called? I forget. The mean-looking store dog from '11) and the VR 2nd gen are looking pretty sweet. So, yeah, very much overpay, in the technical sense. Demand-wise, I have no idea.

[Morphius]

Is a Purple Toxic + Green Sorbet fair for an UR Cucumber?
If not; what would need to be changed?

Thanks in advance :]

[Hekomi]

I apologise, I'm remaking this thread far earlier than normal because I am going to be away most of the day.
viewtopic.php?f=20&p=36957950#p36957938

Sorry guys. ;u; I usually wait until 900 but I think it'll hit that while I'm gone and I don't want to tax the server. Next one will be open to 900 for sure. but feel free to move over there since I'll lock this one.